Skip to content
Logo of blog www.exploitingchange.com by Alcera Consulting Inc.
  • About
    • Richard Martin
    • Alcera Consulting Inc.
  • Services
    • Consulting
    • Facilitation
    • Training
    • Speaking
  • Blog
  • About
    • Richard Martin
    • Alcera Consulting Inc.
  • Services
    • Consulting
    • Facilitation
    • Training
    • Speaking
  • Blog
Contact
  1. Home
  2. »
  3. Books
  4. »
  5. Is It Truly Good to Great, Or Just a Coin Toss?

Is It Truly Good to Great, Or Just a Coin Toss?

Share this post

  • Richard Martin
  • June 1, 2010
  • 10:32 am
  • No Comments
Picture of Richard Martin

Richard Martin

Richard Martin empowers leaders to outmaneuver uncertainty and drive change through strategic insight and transformative thinking.
All Posts

Books like Good to Great are based on survivor bias. Study a bunch of companies that have had an unbroken run of success (By whatever arbitrary criterion you choose. Why 20 years? Why not 21.5 years?) In the universe of all companies, there are bound to be a few that meet your criteria, even though 99 % of companies eventually fail, go out of business, or get bought out. It’s like taking a group of 10000 people and asking them to flip a coin. Every time they flip, you only keep those people that guess right on the coin toss. After a certain number of iterations, there is one person who “successfully” predicted 18 coin tosses in a row (or whatever the number would be). Does that indicate the winner is psychic? After that, you find some arbritrary features that you decide must explain the “success.” Write a book about it, with many compelling – yet just so – stories.

The problem with stories is that they make a great read, convey a point or illustrate with an example. None of these have anything to do with whether there is actually something to be explained in repeated cause and effect terms. The other problem with these books is that they isolate causes of success after the success has occurred, and despite the fact that there is a fair dosage of luck involved (though not always). The resulting advice often appears to be useful on the surface, but there are no real guideposts indicating how to apply it. We’re told that it’s essential to concentrate and adopt the hedgehog approach. What about all the cases where it would have been better to be a generalist? Zen like Level 5 Leadership is the way to go, except that most of the truly exceptional business innovators and leaders are petty tyrants (Jobs, young Gates, etc.). Innovate and be out front, except when you shouldn’t. In fact, for the latter, you could argue that it is the foolhardy thing to do. It’s probably much better to see which way the wind is blowing, and then to bet on a small number of the most likely winners, accepting that you could be totally wrong.

© 2010 Richard Martin


Discover more from Exploiting Change

Subscribe to get the latest posts sent to your email.

Leave a Reply Cancel reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Ready to

Navigate change and strengthen your strategy?

Let’s get started.

Book a call

Share this post

Richard Martin, President of Alcera Consulting Inc.

Richard Martin

Richard Martin is the President of Alcera Consulting Inc., a strategic advisory firm collaborating with top-level leaders to provide strategic insight, navigate uncertainty, and drive transformative change, ensuring market dominance and excellence in public governance. He is the author of Brilliant Manoeuvres: How to Use Military Wisdom to Win Business Battles and the creator of the blog ExploitingChange.com. Richard is also the developer of Strategic Epistemology, a groundbreaking theory that focuses on winning the battle for minds in a world of conflict by dismantling opposing worldviews and ideologies through strategic narrative and archetypal awareness.

PrevPreviousApple’s Brilliant Application of Timeless Military Principles
NextSo You Think It’s Easy to Lead During a Crisis?Next

Business Under Threat: Rethinking Free Enterprise in an Era of State Mobilization

Read More »

Strategic Calibration: Leadership in a Sovereign-Constrained World

Read More »

Coherence Under Fire: Why Enterprise Requires Alignment, Not Autonomy, in a Sovereign World

Read More »
Page1 Page2 Page3 Page4 Page5

You've come this far...

Ready to build a strategy

That is truly impactful?

Book a call

Logo of www.exploitingchange.com blog, by Alcera Consulting Inc.

I collaborate with top-level leaders to provide strategic insight, navigate uncertainty, and drive transformative change, ensuring market dominance and excellence in public governance.

Contact me

+1 (514) 453-3993

Latest Articles

  • Business Under Threat: Rethinking Free Enterprise in an Era of State Mobilization
  • Strategic Calibration: Leadership in a Sovereign-Constrained World
  • Coherence Under Fire: Why Enterprise Requires Alignment, Not Autonomy, in a Sovereign World

Links

  • About
    • Richard Martin
    • Alcera Consulting Inc.
  • Services
    • Consulting
    • Facilitation
    • Training
    • Speaking
  • Blog
  • About
    • Richard Martin
    • Alcera Consulting Inc.
  • Services
    • Consulting
    • Facilitation
    • Training
    • Speaking
  • Blog

Sign up for weekly insights

Sign up for weekly insights

We don’t spam! Read more in our privacy policy

Check your inbox or spam folder to confirm your subscription.

Privacy Policy – Terms & conditions

Alcera Consulting Inc. © 2024 Copyright - All Rights Reserved

Socials

X-twitter